A Tragic End - Instablogs
A Tragic End
Jay , Mumbai: Oct 28 2008
Made Popular Oct 28 2008
India :

A Tragic End

This week promised to be full of joy and excitement as everyone got in the festive mood of celebrating Diwali. It started with Dhanteras falling on Sunday, when one would buy gold or new items for their homes or for themselves. One could see the crowds pouring on the road, there was hardly any place to walk or for the vehicles to drive through causing traffic jams All this despite there being a shadow of the economy gloom looming over.

What nobody expected was how on a Monday morning going to work would end up in a harrowing time for a few commuters who found themselves being held hostage in a double decker bus that they were traveling in. In the end of the drama that ensued, the gunman was shot down by the cops. One wonders what prompted a 23 year old boy Rahul Raj to stage such a hostage situation. What were his demands?

It turns out that he hailed from Bihar. He wrote on currency notes that he wanted to kill Raj Thackrey and wanted to talk to the Police Commissioner. He said he did not want to hurt anyone. The one question that comes to the mind is was his killing justified given the circumstances and in view of his demands? Could the situation have been better handled?

One of the ironies that I failed to understand that where were this responsible cops when the MNS workers were burning places when Raj Thackrey was arrested. They vehemently justifies their act of killing someone whose demands was more kind of a voice that needed to be heard and not asking for any ransom in return of the hostages. After knowing the intentions of the boy, the cops could have handled the situation tactfully by calming him and keeping the shootout option as a last resort.

A voice that wanted to be heard though the method adopted was wrong. This goes on to show the disparity that is showing signs of being blown out of proportion because of regional politics. Monday’s incident just happens to be a small trigger of what could be installed next, if individuals like Rahul Raj decided they had enough of this and want action to be taken.

Times were different when acting as saviors of “Marathi Manoos” worked for his uncle earlier. This act won’t work today as the people of today are knowledgeable about what is happening around them, what is good and bad for them. Though the same cannot be told about the small section of the society who support this wrongly aimed cause.

Who are these “Marathi Manoos” for which political parties vie for by playing the local card? Why do they want reservations for them in every job openings? Don’t they believe in competing? What would Mumbai be if the gujratis did not set up their shops here and started trading? How about the south indians who dominate the hotel industry? What was the Marathi Manoos doing when people from other states migrated to make their dreams come true? Should they be made to pay for realizing their dreams and being competitive?

Mumbai would not have become a financial hub of the country if it was not for ‘immigrants’ who made this possible. This does not mean that people from the Marathi community are left behind. They have also made their mark in the various fields be it writing, sports, bollywood, etc. and we all know about the prominent people be it Sunil Gavaskar, Vijay Tendulkar and others. It is really pathetic to see educated people stooping so low so that they could gather a vote bank for themselves.

The tragic death of Rahul Raj is just a beginning of how worse things can go. If nothing is done soon enough there could more trouble brewing up. What is appalling is that people prefer to divide themselves by state boundaries and we thought that it was only the British rule which succeeded in doing it.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
Your article really touched my heart
1 Stars
Lalit
Kanpur, India
The Mumbai police could have done without killing him. The ruling Congress/NCP alliance in Maharashtra have been shaken by the recent Marathi Manus movement started by Raj Thackeray. Therefore it ordered the police to fire to kill the youth from Patna.
1 Stars
Julie
New Delhi, India
This is the last thing Mumbai wanted after all that has happened in the recent past with Raj Thackeray and his goons. This country belongs to all of us and Mumbai and Maharashtra is not foreign land. Any Indian would get agitated like Rahul Raj.
1 Stars
Puneet
Noida, India
I heard that the Crime Branch of Mumbai police will carry out a high level inquiry into the killing of the Bihari youth Rahul Raj in yesterday's drama. This is almost insult to injury for the bereaved family members and the victim as well. Lalu is right to have called for an independent inquiry by a sitting Supreme Court judge.
1 Stars
Avadhut
Calicut, India
There isn't an iota of doubt that the Mumbai police fired to kill the man they could have easily overpowered or wore down with tiredness. They shot him because he was from Bihar. If he was a Marathi or a Gujarati then things would have been different.
1 Stars
Ankita
Thane, India
Incredible though it might sound, I fully support what the Mumbai police did. How can a man go on and brandish a weapon threatening to kill a person. It shows absolutely no regard for law. He could have killed someone.
1 Stars
Jay
Mumbai, India
Hi Ankita

Shootout should always be kept as a last resort in a hostage crisis situation.

I am not sure if you are aware that a similar incident had taken place 5 yrs back, where a CISF constable Ramnarayan Namdeo shot dead his superior officer for not granting him leave with his rifle at the departure lounge of the airport. He had six people as hostage with him.

The cops were successful in making him surrender after using negotiation tactics with him.

The point that I am trying to make is we should know the difference between a criminal and a person who wants his voice to be heard. Demands laid during such crisis tells a lot about what they stand for.
1 Stars
Avadhut
Calicut, India
This tragic incidence has completely spoiled the mood of many of our countrymen just before the Diwali festival because of the insensitivity shown by the trigger happy and encounter specialist Mumbai police.
1 Stars
Nitesh
Chennai, India
This tragic episode has brought all the top leaders of Bihar together cutting across party lines. It was refreshing to see Nitish Kumar, Sushil Modi standing together with Lalu Prasad and Ram Vilas Paswan.
1 Stars
Manishkumar
Kottayam, India
I agree with Laloo Prasad Yadav that MNS and Shiv Sena be banned as anti-national groups and charges of sedition be brought against Raj Thackeray and whoever plays the regionalist card. This is unacceptable in India.
1 Stars
Syeda
Dhaka, Bangladesh
The Shiv Sena and Bal Thackeray persecuted Bengalis and tried to forcibly deport many Indian Bengalis to Bangladesh branding them as illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. Rest of India did not do much. Now see what is happening to people from other Indian states.
1 Stars
Irfan
Islamabad, Pakistan
First Bal Thakrey and his extremist party killed Muslims and now they are killing Hindus who have come from other states to Mumbai to earn a living. They must learn a few things from Pakistan that allows lakhs of Afghanis to work in Pakistan.
2 Stars
Bhupender Bhatia -
ludhiana, India
Article is true picture of present.
1 Stars
Vijay
Kota, India
Jay,alls are equal irespective of cast creed and colour and this countries constitution provide equal opportunities to them.Then why this difference? of Marathi Manoos and others.Its everywhere in Maharashtra and in Educational institutions also.
Add your Comment